That’s the joke. Also known as: Rose Ann DeMoro, Sal Rosselli and Andrew Stern walk into a – shit some Black dude just died. Why is it that more than a year after David Smith’s death at the 2008 Labor Notes conference there is still no one laughing?
The Setup
The Sevice Employees International Union (SEIU) butts heads with the California Nurses Association (CNA) in a power grab for members. SEIU accuses CNA of union-busting. CNA accuses SEIU collaborating to undermine patient care. Both sides accuse each other of violence and dirty tactics.
The United Healthcare Workers West (UHW) local head up by Sal Rosselli sides with CNA resulting in his ousting and trusteeship of the local. Sal Rosselli and Rose Ann DeMoro (Executive Director of the CNA) are slotted as keynote speakers at the 2009 Labor Notes conference and as the situation escalates conference registrations soar to record levels. Sal Rosselli cancels the engagement due to legal issues. In the midst of violence against CNA in Ohio Rose Ann DeMoro also cancels the speaking engagement instead opting to send a video taped message.
Meanwhile, one of the vendors setting up in the lobby of the banquet hall casually informs me that for a conference that’s so tight on security the huge unsupervised lobby doors that give direct access to the banquet hall from the outside sure did seem a risk. i informed conference organizer and co-executive director Marsha Neijemer of the situation who blew it off as a non-issue.
Execution
SEIU “purple shirts” disrupt the entire health care track of workshops, flyer the conference hotel with propaganda and by Saturday Co-Directors Mark Brenner and Marsha Neijemer decide to ban them from the conference. There are rumors of a large disruption set to occur with bus loads of SEIU protesters. By the mid-afternoon there is an emergency staff meeting to announce the decision to introduce Dearborn police – notorious for their inefficacy, brutality and racism – to the mix during the evening keynote. In addition to the police presence Mark and Marsha identify in-house “security” prepared to act in case of disturbance and to remove banned SEIU protestors. Another element of their ingenious plan is to post Mischa Gaus – co-editor and healthcare track organizer – at the hotel entrance to the banquet hall lobby and cull the undesirables sight-on-seen from the over 1000 conference participants. Accordingly they post Mischa, “security” and police at this entrance, inside the building, rather than the entrance that leads outside. By the time people begin streaming into the banquet hall for the keynote there are confirmed reports of several buses of SEIU people in the mall parking lot adjacent to the hotel.
Shortly before the intended start time of the evening keynote the ill-fated plan collapses resulting in a nightmare scenario. One of the SEIU protesters slips past the watchful eye of Mischa and opens the door to hundreds of SEIU protesters who swarm the banquet hall lobby unhindered by the lack of security or police coverage at the crucial entrance. Many of the protesters are women and children smattered with a few SEIU thugs, large white men that had the obvious intention of turning the situation into a physical altercation, who clash with Labor Notes “security”. The doors to the banquet hall are shut trapping some 700 people, many of them undocumented workers who, combined with the police presence, are terrified of an ICE raid. In the lobby a group of primarily white Labor Notes staff and allies (including myself and another POC – then intern now assistant editor – Paul Abowd) form a human chain linking arms to block entry to the banquet hall from the largely Black and local crowd of SEIU protesters. This image, of white lined up against Black in Detroit, is one that has lasted with me as a metaphor for the city, the conference and the labor movement organizing here.
Some of the subsequent interaction is caught on video, where police are also captured doing shit all to improve the situation. Beside me Dianne Feeley, an elderly Labor Notes founder, is pushed in the mileu and on her way down she hits a vendor table that splits her head open. The person who knocked her over asks her if she’s alright and Dianne replies that no, she is not. One of the nurses ushers her aside and tends to her wound. Chris Kutalik – former editor – exclaims for the first time of several, almost in tears, “They hurt Dianne!” Everything happens quickly, there is more pushing and many of the people i have tumultuously worked alongside for the past months are assaulted, including Mischa who is punched in they eye. A Black woman wearing a purple shirt calls me a bitch. i say: “sis’ how can you say that?” She says: “you ain’t my sister.”
The punch-line
There is a soon-to-be dead man collapsed on the concrete outside. His name is David Smith and he had the unfortunate luck of being unionized with SEIU. He also had the unfortunate luck of attending a conference organized by people so intersted in concentrating power that they lacked the good sense to prevent, in the most basic and obvious ways, the events that led to his death. Like so many Black Detroiters he had the unfortunate luck of serving as an afterthought in his own city.
The Monday after the conference Ken Paff, a Labor Notes insider, writes a wry account of what is termed by Labor Notes staff as “the invasion” making no mention of David Smith. In an incredible show of patronizing post-mortem humiliation SEIU produces an obituary for David Smith centering largely around his literacy issues. The SEIU’s National AFRAM Caucus condemns the exploitation of African American women and children to no response or acknowledgment. Despite the loss of life the Labor Notes website lauds the conference as an unprecedented success.
The incident serves as a catalyst to issues of internal racism that result in my dismissal from the organization shortly thereafter. When asked why he felt i was “threatening”, Mischa Gaus tells me, “because you say things like ‘i refuse to be silenced’.” It took me over a year to prove him right.
POSTSCRIPT: On March 19 of this year, less than a month from the one-year anniversary of David Smith’s death, SEIU and the CNA announced a historic agreement to divy up hospital workers. Neither organization has taken responsibility for the wrongful death of David Smith. Labor Notes has yet to report on his death or the issues raised by AFRAM in any comprehensive way.
Phyrecracker